Random

What are the most important issues facing Orthodoxy?

As a sociologist of the frum community, I’m on a constant quest to figure our strange little community out. In the process of this, I’ve ruffled a few feathers, stirred a few pots, and pissed off some of those folks who have power to throw you in cherem and throw away the key. However, I’ve been wondering lately what the most important issues facing orthodoxy today. It’s an ever changing list, full of surprises and like anything involving Jews, full of opinions. Of course, I’m not just here to point out our problems, I’m trying to bring about some sort of change or reflection on the subject.

Shidduchim: No seems to be willing to admit that there’s been a shift in the way we do things with regards to marriage and dating. Shidduch dating has become passe, people are waiting longer to marry and we continue to blame it on things like the never-proven age gap theory and secular society’s ideals creeping into our culture.

Sex Abuse: Like the Catholics, it’s taken us many years to come to terms with our failures in this regard, Slowly (slower than I can really believe) the community is beginning to acknowledge that a problem exists. They aren’t quite sure what to do about it, as many people still believe that telling the authorities makes you liable for the death penalty, but as modern orthodoxy and more liberal black hat folks come to terms with this problem, you can look for more cooperation with authorities.

Women and the increasing “modesty”: I know that many of you think that it’s funny that Charedim are ever increasing their tznius standards, which include blocking out women from print media, preventing women from attending key events, and failing to mention their names on announcements. However, these are important issues, because it’s becoming increasingly strict, divisive, and a driving force in the case against women. At some point people may realize that using tznius as an excuse to mistreat women is no way to uphold modesty.

Gays: It’s not that the frum community has such a large gay population, but the fact that gay marriage is on the forefront of religious debate. This means that the Orthodox community will have to increasingly deal with a more open minded populace as they try to stick true to their religious values without being labeled as homophobes. I’m not sure how religious groups will deal with this key issue.

Off The Derech: The community of those who have left Orthodoxy is growing quickly, it is vocal, and it has influence whether you like it or not. The OTD community is both important and threatening, I’m certian that you will see more outreach from both sides. There will be what I may term as reverse kiruv.

Rising Costs: It’s darned expensive to be Orthodox and plenty of people have what to say about it, yeshiva tuition, food costs, and housing in major frum centers are all a worry to those in the community. I’m not really certian what we can do about it, but it seems that more and more people are moving out of the major frum cities on the East Coast to the smaller out of town communities. It will be interesting to see if other major frum centers pop up. The idea to send kids to public school never really worked, vouchers are stuck in the courts, and yeshivas are overflowing.

Internet: Despite the efforts of some people to ban the internet, more and more folks are on the internet than ever before. There is the general fear that once exposed to the secular ideals available on the internet, will people leave their communities due to their internet usage. Is it possible that internet will have an overall positive effect on the frum community.

Rising Divorce Rates: It was only time until the frum community caught up to the general community in this regard. No longer can we look at our shidduch system and say that it works, people aren’t getting married and more and more folks are getting divorced. It’s nothing special to meet 25 year old single mothers of 2 in the frum community. I’m not sure what we can do to prevent such things, but I think a lot of people talk about marriage, without talking about staying married. The shidduch crisis is not merely as scary as the looming divorce crisis.

Find out more on 4torah.com

 

 

Letters to the Editor 19 letters since 2013

  1. Yeshiva monopoly–families are more worried about appearing “right” for yeshiva admission committees than they are about the shadchanim. Kids are forced to start younger and younger. Families lie about TV and Internet access. Meanwhile, the quality of education is slipping.

  2. Hesh u gotta check out this new resteraunt coffee place in monsey o its caleed yofi coffee @ rt 59 by the 711 , Its milf, frummy ,tuna beigal center. Its bound to overtake the 7 11 as a hangout.

  3. good post and points Heshy, but I don’t fully agree
    re: the Rising Costs- it’s not that costs have risen as much as today’s grandparents cannot afford to subsidize costs the way their parents did for them. Suddenly the well is empty and the money just doesn’t exist. Friends of my generation who stayed in America had more kids and less money than their parents, and they barely have the money to retire. Their kids (your generation) have to budget and it hurts.

    re: Off The Derech- again a generational thing. BT was big in my generation and many of our kids take after their grandparents. The pendulum swings…

  4. About them agunot, folks … it amazes me that even if the rabbanim couldn’t care less about the personal hell each and every agunah is going through right now, they don’t seem concerned about the loss to the community of these women’s unborn children (every agunah who spends her childbearing years chained to some sorry excuse for a Jewish “man” is undergoing de facto sterilization) and what kind of impact the children of these marriages will have on the shidduch scene when they are old enough to start dating.
    I shudder to think of the baggage my own sons will bring to their future marriages – assuming they are not permanently scared off marriage by what they saw going on at home.

    1. They do think about those things… that’s why they hold by halacha, so as to prevent the stigma of being an adulteress or a mamzer and making sure they and their children can (re-) marry, to maximize the number of people whom they can marry

  5. The lack of a proper education common amongst the orthodox, esp the ultra-orthodox, or the child abuse issues and how the orthodox community is set up in such a way that it often protects the abusers.

  6. Great post. I agree with all of it. The worst part is you can’t talk to anyone about these issues because you are looked at as having a problem. Or you are given the talk to a rav answer which to me always feels like a lecture of brainwashing.

  7. The mentality that community means people think exactly alike when it should mean that we look out for each other and stick together. The idea of the Jewish community reminds me of the “Wrinkle In Time.” You know how all the houses are alike and all the kids come out and bounce their balls exACTLY together in a creepy way…

Write a letter to the editor

Random