Random

YU revises history, shmistory.

Nothing restores my faith in the fine institution known as Yeshiva University when they act more like a Yeshiva and less like a University.  This past Rosh Hashanna I had the pleasure to read their latest YU To-Go.  This publication shows me why I’m glad I didn’t spend my parent’s money on YU tuition.  You can get the same mal-education and krum-scholarship elsewhere.

Harsh you say?  Consider this gem.  One of the articles discusses a seriously scholarly topic — Why is there a difference in approach to many events between Sefer Melachim and Sefer Divrei Hayamim (the Biblical books of Kings and Chronicles for those of you maskilim who didn’t go to a Yeshiva at all).  Both books cover a similar time-frame, and yet, there are discrepancies in their stories.  So far, you think that this must be a scholarly article.  Now the author clarifies:  According to Chazal, Yirmiyahu (aka Jeremiah) wrote Sefer Melachim.  He also wrote his own book and the scroll of Eicha.  However, according to Chazal, Ezra Hasofer wrote Sefer Divrei Hayamim.  OK — this is a pretty safe approach by suggesting that Chazal were right (of course they were) and that we simply have two authors writing about the same period of history. Understandably they will probably report the facts  slightly differently. Right?

Now this is neither particularly sophisticated, nor scholarly accurate, but then again I was just expecting fluffy stuff from YU anyway.  It’s not like this is the old Shavuah Ivri of the Histadrut, where you have real scholars discussing these topics.  But then it hits me like a ton of bricks.  This is not just stam narishkeit I’m reading — it’s downright purim–toirah.

The author explains that is more than just author’s perspective at play, we’re also dealing with a different period of time.  Whereas most people know that Ezra lived about a hundred years after Jeremiah — according to the author in this edition of YU To Go, Ezra lives One Thousand years later!

Excerpt from YU To Go

Yes, this makes Ezra into an Amorah living in the 6th century!

By contrast, Divrei Hayamim was written in a very different time period than the destruction of the Beit Hamikdash.  Chazal explain that Ezra wrote Divrei Hayamim during the period of Shivat Tziyon, which began in 538 CE, nearly one thousand years after the destruction of the first Beit Hamikdash in 586 BCE. […] Ezra is able to look at his people’s history with a thousand years having passed.

There’s not much to say about this this.  At first I thought this was a printer’s mistake, but then I realized that this is the author’s thesis.  According to her, Ezra really lived 1000 years after the destruction of the first temple.  And the editor of YU To Go let this through.  I could not be making this up if I wanted to.

YU to Go

This is published by YU’s Center for the Jewish Future, where history is shmistory.  A shanda.

Am I being too harsh?  Should a simple mistake be allowed? You tell me in the comments below.  What should the expectation be for this kind of journal?

Read more history, shmistory on 4Torah.com

Letters to the Editor 46 letters since 2020

    1. Editor’s Note: We would like to acknowledge the error in “Sachar V’Onesh? Addressing Suffering as We Look to the New Year” in this year’s Rosh Hashana To-Go 5772. It has been fixed on the on line version. It was due to an editorial mistake and was not what the author had intended. We thank our engaged readers who pointed it out. Chag kasher v’sameach

      http://www.yutorah.org/togo/sukkot/

  1. I don’t know what happened, but if you download a copy from yutorah.org the offending passages have been replaced.

    “By contrast, Divrei Hayamim was written in a very different time period than the destruction of the Beit Hamikdash. Chazal explain that Ezra wrote Sefer Divrei Hayamim during the period of Shivat Tzion. During Shivat Tzion…”

    “Perhaps for this reason, Divrei Hayamim is so focused on Torat Hagmul. While Yirmiyahu is too close to the situation to gain a real perspective on the big picture, Ezra is able to look at the broader perspective.The wound…”

  2. You’re a dummy, Ezra is looking at the entire 1,000 year history of the Jews entering Eretz Yisrael, tekufat haShofetim, malchut bet David, galut, and geula.

    1. That is a nice explanation but it doesn’t go with the flow following the statement that it was written 1.000 years later.

      That is like saying Holocaust happened 1,000 years ago… and David Wyman’s was able to write the book Abandonment of the Jews with a thousand years having passed.

  3. Is this post some titillating Purim Torah foreplay for what you’re planning for this fine New Year? The Kefira and Reformodoxy of the ‘Gedolim’ of YU is a Nachas for us all. I mean c’mon… lets face it… I have yet to hear a serious discussion on any matter important to the Frum velt where someone pipes up.. “but Gadol Rabbi or Rabbah from YU paskened X etc.”! Personally, I like YU alot!! perhaps not for the reasons a frum person should really like em like em. I’m doing Tshuva (at least I’m trying) but them Stern students are my ticket to some serious Al Chait klopping!!

    Gmar Chasima Tova Heshy!!

    1. Such is the power of Heshy’s Pulitzer Prize potential.

      He has only to write a semi-satiric article and the cream of American rabbinical talent crumbles!

      1. No. But it’s a lot better than “We have one book with no supporting evidence, no independent corroboration, no historical record and no physical evidence.”

        There’s plenty of evidence for the Treaty of Versailles. We have the original document. We have multiple independent accounts from people of vastly different perspectives. We have the minutes of the negotiations over the treaty. We have records for years later of the Allied Powers demanding the Germans pay up and of the Germans trying to negotiate within the terms of the treaty.

        In short, your analogy sucks flatus out of stillborn orangutans.

      2. Something ate the reply. Munch. Munch
        No. But it’s a lot better than “We have one book with no supporting evidence, no independent corroboration, no historical record and no physical evidence.”

        There’s plenty of evidence for the Treaty of Versailles. We have the original document. We have multiple independent accounts from people of vastly different perspectives. We have the minutes of the negotiations over the treaty. We have records for years later of the Allied Powers demanding the Germans pay up and of the Germans trying to negotiate within the terms of the treaty.

        In short, your analogy is lame as a three legged cockroach

    1. You are right partially, there is no concrete archeological evidence but we have found artifacts in Jerusalem dating to that time period. Also, the bible is a primary source, as historians and archaeologists have proved so we shouldn’t rule out its testimonies either.

      wikipedia
      By 2006, the Temple Mount Antiquities Salvage Operation had recovered numerous artifacts dating from the 8th to 7th centuries BCE from dirt removed in 1999 by the Islamic Religious Trust (Waqf) from the Solomon’s Stables area of the Temple Mount. These include stone weights for weighing silver and a First Temple period bulla, or seal impression, containing ancient Hebrew writing which includes the name Netanyahu ben Yaush. Netanyahu is a name mentioned several times in the Book of Jeremiah while the name Yaush appears in the Lachish letters. However, the combination of names was unknown to scholars.

    2. Most of that era’s history is unconfirmed. The first epoch of Jewish History that can be confirmed is the Assyrian conquest, as the Assyrians kept great records. In fact, the Assyrian side of the story changes quite a few things. According to them, Chizkiyahu spent quite some time trying to get an audience with their king, and when he finally got it, he was on his hands and knees begging him not to attack his kingdom (a fact very much glossed over by the Nevi’im, who merely mention him paying a heavy tribute). Also, the sudden disappearance of Sennacherib’s army…the Navi calls it a miracle. A simple study of Assyrian History provides the answer to that question. The Assyrian Garrisons in (Egypt, I think) were under heavy fire, and they needed serious backup, and this was of strategic importance, so the Assyrians withdrew from Judea suddenly to help out. They did not just suddenly disappear! They withdrew, and for a good reason.

      1. ghottistyx- Why would you believe the Assyrian side any more? If both sides agree the event took place and give different accounts, all I take out of it is the basic details they agree on. Actually no. More accurately, I think the Navi doesn’t intentionally lie (as far as I can recall. I’m no scholar.). There are many accounts recorded that make the Jewish heroes look terrible. The only thing to take into account always is that God is front and center in the authors’ minds. So you get an unusually honest account of the human activities (even by today’s standards), but you can take or leave the Godly activities depending on how much you believe.
        The honesty in the book does make me pause and consider the miraculous accounts seriously though. Public spectacles like Eliyahu on Har Hacarmel especially.

        1. (yawn) a very God-centric view of Jewish History. How delightful.

          By their viewpoint, Menashe was the worst thing that ever happened to the Kingdom of Judea. However, if you look at it, Menashe actually was probably the greatest politician of the kings since Mr. Thousand-Women Diplomacy himself. In the 50 years that he was King, he very cleverly worked with the situation between the Egyptians, Assyrians, burgeoning Babylonians, etc. in order to ensure the safety of his own kingdom. Of course, reading the Navi, you only see hints of this brilliance dropped, as they are very quick to say that he’s the one who caused the Torah to be all-but-completely forgotten, thus setting off the chain reaction of that ever-jealous Lord’s wrath that led to the eminent unraveling of the Space-Time continuum (wait, wrong movie…the destruction of the First Temple).

          So was the Navi lying? No, it was merely pressing the agenda of the YHWH-thumpers who had a clear moral outlook on how a King should behave, and Menashe did not fit it. In their eyes, he was a terrible, horrible man. But there’s always more sides to a story than one primary source (if the Navi can be considered one) tells. Remember that when assessing just how honest our Tanach really is. If one were to only read the Illiad and nothing else on the Trojan War, would they have a clear picture of what really transpired?

  4. Speaking of Rosh Hashana, I’ve recently foudn a great way to greet the people of holy land Israel for Rosh Hashana, a new project held by the Ministry of Diplomacy: ecards automatically translated into Hebrew.
    Very nice and worth checking (I just got a beautiful ecard from a guy living in Haifa Israel… nice gesture indeed)

    http://bit.ly/nkap3u

    1. Which departments? Which programs? By what standard? It’s not even in the same universe as the Ivies, the Little Ivies, the tech schools, the high-caliber liberal arts schools ir special-purpose institutions like the Colorado School of Mines.

  5. Why does everyone love to bash YU?

    I went to a chareidi yeshiva, a tziyoni yeshiva, an ivy league school, possibly the best public university in the world, and likely the best non-ivy private university in the country, AND YU. And even with all that I have to compare it to, I still think YU is a great school. Why do YOU hate it so much?

    And, YU has already pulled the problematic text from it’s download site (yutorah.org) so they obviously don’t support the thesis. At minimum, please revise your post to note that.

    Gmar Chasima Tova!

    1. It is so noted — YU revised history. No, I mean revised their history again. But this time the revision was of the revision — so it’s good. I’m glad we got that straight. We’re good now. It was a mistake. But it’s fixed. My post is moot.

      YU is the best. I love YU.
      Rav Rav Rav.

      1. YU at least has the integrity to go back and correct its errors; their retraction undermines your whole assumption that YU supported this position rather than it being just a da’as yachid.

        You on the other hand, have left your ‘retraction’ at the bottom of a pile of comments… Seems like the YU guys and their education have bested you here!

        1. Dear Heshy or FS editor,
          Please add a disclaimer to this post for me. Otherwise YU is better than me.

          You can indicate that the vast majority of YU people are total scholars. Mistakes happen. And when people point them out, they are bashing YU.

          As for my education — I wen to Telz — the home of history, shimstory; didkduk, smikduk; education, shmeducation. We never even heard of Divrei Hayamim. We thought that the book of Chronicles was that old bar mitzva gift of those tall thin books that turned the bible stories into a newspaper. The whole Tanach was not frum enough for us — let alone a women who dares to write a dvar torah.

          1. You load your comments with sarcasm, but that is exactly what you did, you did a whole intro bashing YU and then supported it/justified it by quoting a da’as yachid that YU has disavowed.

            I know where you are coming from. In my yeshiva we were innovative and learned some Nach — but only those prakim that were in Haftoros.

          2. Me? sarcasm? on a satire blog? naah… couldn’t be.
            This is a critical and scholarly review blog.

            You’ll find the sarcasm on YWN and VIN. You’ll find the jokes on Rational Torah and Hirhurim, but on Frum Satire, you’ll only find honest news reporting with no sarcasm, and a very high level of scholarship.

            Don’t you read the other posts?

      1. Williams, Reed, Scripps, Stanford, Dartmouth, St. Johns, Annapolis, MIT, Cal Tech, Amherst, Duke….

        There’s a lot of good schools out there. It depends on what you want to study.

        YU doesn’t even come within sight of the top tier.

  6. This is the “author’s thesis”? I doubt it. Someone who should know better made an incredibly silly mistake (that’s an understatement – but the ten days of repentance are a time for understated insults, not the usual over the top kind) in confusing CE for BCE, and editors who should know better didn’t catch it.

    I’m amused but not impressed that there is anything here but a crude error compounded by an apparent lack of appreciation for even the crudest timeline of Jewish History.

    1. An-on
      At first I too thought it was a spelling error. Then I re-read the article and it became clear that the thesis was that Ezra’s distance provided him with the ability to see things that Yirmiyahu did not. Which, BTW, is not the scholarly reason that Divrei Hayamin and Melachim differ. So when I carefully read the article, I realized that this was more than an error in spelling, but in knowledge.

      1. It may have been intended to say a hundred years distance provided a different perspective, and the B of BCE was omitted and then the error was compunded

        1. Had the corrected version (online — see links above) indicated what you just suggested, your theory would have been proven correct.

  7. Chofetz Chaim guys always put down YU. It’s important for them to do so as all the other Chareidi Yeshivos put down Chafetz Chaim. Lakewood puts down Ner Yisrael. Etc etc etc. Whether he has a point or not, there is probably a cultural point of origin for his statements. And I think the CC guys are all really nice. That’s just the deal. Oh and BTW, YU guys–the really serious ones–secretly think that everyone else is light-weight. And–in some ways–they are.

  8. Anon, the people I know do and they do put it down if you ask them. If you don’t ask them, they don’t have any cause to talk about it. Not on their radar. Whatever. Not important at this time.

  9. Who doesn’t put down other sects of Judaism? Every sect feels they are right.

    I davened at a MO shul, and all they spoke about was the bad Yeshiva people.

    MO people also put down Chassidim.

    Chassidim say that Yeshivish people are not Jewish because they don’t speak Yiddish.

Write a letter to the editor

Random