
The internet is abuzz with the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge – everyone’s got an opinion on it, everyone knows they can find a way to show off their skills while having cold water dumped on their heads, everyone’s passing on the challenge to someone more choshuv than themselves in a bid to raise their social chashivus. And that’s all good, that’s how social philanthropy works.
In this vein NJ governor Chris Christie challenged Mark Zuckerberg, who in turn challenged Bill Gates.
Bill Gates showed us that he should have been a guillotine designer, while the OTD Godol, Rachmuna Litzlon showed us that he’s on Facebook even while having water poured over his head.
As you can see from my Facebook profile picture I am perpetually glued to my gemarah so I don’t have time for these social challenges, but I’m reminded of the time I had a cup of freezing cold water poured over my sleeping head.
You see I didn’t become a masmid recently, I’ve been this way since tenth grade. Back in tenth grade while we were learning the first three blatt of Bava Kamma ad nauseam I, and a good friend, were busy trying to finish the mesechta. It was the winter zman and a leap year, so we had an extra month in which to finish it. During the morning shiur where the magid shiur was trying to make sense of a shtickle Pnei Yehoishua and Mafteach L’Talmud I was quickly learning Shor Shenagach Daled V’hay (the 4th perek). During night seder I zoomed ahead and finished Hagozel U’machil (the 10th perek), on Shabbos afternoons I was learning Perek Merubah (the 7th perek) and at 5:30 AM I would learn with my friend Dovid. First we finished the parts of Hogozel Eitzim (the 9th perek) that the yeshiva didn’t cover during seder and then we spent that time doing chazarah on stuff we had learned at other times.
One night we were both up very late watching a movie in our secret hideout. It was early morning by the time were were ready to go to sleep and I was afraid that if I went to sleep I wouldn’t be able to wake up at 5:30, but I didn’t want to stay up all night because I knew I wouldn’t be able to learn that day if I did. Dovid had a little contraption he had built on the wall above his pillow; it was a little pulley connected to his alarm clock that would tip a cup of water onto his head. He needed a silent alarm clock so he wouldn’t wake up all his roommates, but he needed one that would be powerful enough to wake him up. It worked every time, he was always up on time.
Dovid said he’d stay up the rest of the night and offered me his bed, he said he’d set up the water clock to wake me up at 5:30 and I’d meet him in the beis medrish afterwards. I lay down in his bed and fell promptly into a deep sleep, I was exhausted.
I know what waterboarding feels like and I sympathize with all those Guantanamo Bay terrorists; I was suddenly awake feeling like I was drowning! That bastard had filled a 12 ounce cup to the brim and stood outside his door laughing his head off while I bolted up gagging and trying to catch my breath. And like Mark Zuckerberg, who simply turned around and said “that was really cold” and walked off like he’d just eaten a chocolate chip cookie, I got up and did chazarah on Keitzad Haregel (2nd perek).
And now that I’ve heroically completed my challenge for the sake of toireh, I challenge America’s Rabbi, Rabbi Shmuley Boteach, The Internet Rabbi, Rabbi Eliyahu Fink and the Frum Satire Rabbi, Rabbi Heshy Fried to complete the challenge or pony up $100.

Shragi,
Sorry, but it seems with all of the fun of the ice-bucket challenges, most people are missing the whole point. There’s nothing remotely funny about ALS. One of our friends, a fellow in his late 50s, coincidentally Jewish, was just diagnosed with ALS. He woke up one morning in June and had a slight speech problem….thought he had a stroke…after a few weeks, they diagnosed him with ALS. It’s a horrific disease, just erodes your motor skills day by day, speech changes get worse gradually, demoralizes family and friends as we sit and watch the gradual breakdown of a vibrant person. The $13.5M or so that have been generated from all of the ice-bucket fun, will really do little to develop a cure. The best and brightest have been working on a cure for over 75 years. Ever since Lou Gehrig gave the “I’m the luckiest man on the face of the earth” speech.
Bill Dwyre, LA Times Sportswriter said it best in a sports section editorial this morning (Aug 19th) “…But at the moment, pouring water on our heads, or each other’s, seems a slightly distasteful disconnect to the reality of ALS. Certainly and hopefully, it is not the intention of people such as LeBron James or Bill Gates or Steve Ballmer or Jimmy Fallon — or the thousands of other celebrity types who have done this and got huge Internet attention — to further their own brand. Still, I wish more had said, when challenged, that pouring water on heads, with its accompanying attention-grabbing and frivolity, didn’t quite mesh with the cause. ALS isn’t the least bit funny.A few did, including the president of the United States.The good news is that the money will keep the researchers researching. The bad news is that $13 million probably doesn’t buy as many test tubes as it used to. The sad news is that we seem to need a viral Internet event to stir us up. And there are so many, disappearing just as fast as they arrive. If this one doesn’t work, lots of people have gotten lots of attention and written big checks that they should have written in private. This too shall pass, even though our current look-at-me era probably won’t. It’s kind of a no-harm, no-foul, good-try thing.”
I guess all I can reasonably ask that we try to say a Mishiberah this Shabbat for my friend David…..Dovid ben Yetta. I will.
Izzy, I’m sorry you find it distasteful. Personally I think that the fact that it raised something like fifteen million dollars is a good thing; is that everything? No, but how is that a bad thing?
http://www.forbes.com/sites/matthewherper/2014/08/19/think-the-ice-bucket-challenge-is-stupid-youre-wrong/
Shragi, I think raising the money is a great thing. I hope it helps but only time will tell. I’ll admit I was a bit over the top in my criticism….I had read Bill Dwyre’s points and combined with our friend who recently was diagnosed with ALS, I kind of vented on you. I know your post was made in the light of satire and my apologies for the slight.
We are waiting for you to complete the challenge.
For me? But I did it already, now it’s Heshy’s turn.
Where is the evidence?