I’m sitting on the tailgate of my car eating some raw almonds, I’m sweaty and I feel damned good, like amazing to be alive. Then I start thinking about what to do next, it’s only 6:45 and I could take a nice leisurely drive up the coast from where I am in Santa Cruz and do an awe inspiring mincha b’yechidus while watching one of Hashem’s coolest creations disappear in a fiery color storm below the Pacific horizon, then the yetzer tov pipes in.
I know what you’re thinking, how on earth is a sunset mincha filled with kavannah a work of the yetzer hara?
My yetzer hara is a strange animal – here’s how it works.
Yetzer Tov: Heshy, you know that if you leave now you will make it on time to shul in Palo Alto where you can daven with a minyan.
Yetzer Hara: Dude, you know you never get a good davening in at that shul, you just won’t have proper kavannah.
Yetzer Tov: Even so, davening with a minyan without kavannah is better than davening alone with kavannah.
Yetzer Hara: Imagine you saying ashrei, dangling your legs off the cliffs at Bonny Doon beach, wind in your hair.
Yezter Tov: You will be able to hear the Rabbi speak between mincha and maariv.
Yetzer Hara: Dude, weren’t you just telling me how you didn’t like the fact that the rabbi didn’t ever speak for that long – remember you brought along your chovos halivovos – you can bust some of that stuff out after mincha and watch the sunset.
Yetzer Tov (the money and blogging tactic): You can save valuable gas money and maybe there will be some interesting happenings in shul to write about.
Yetzer Hara: You work almost every night, how often do you get to see the sunset?
The Yetzer Tov won that time, I think it may have had something to do with the fact I received a parking ticket and thought about how I hadn’t given ma’aser from that paycheck. Tonight the yetzer hara won and I did a mincha in fog ensrhouded redwoods in the middle of a muddy ride, instead of waiting to go to shul. I am sure everyone has strange yetzer hara’s and tov’s – mine sure is, always trying to trick me with the solitude and the view.

Interesting
so that was your yetzer hara? because you know that if you are sure there is gonna be a minyan at shul and you can do better davening alone it is actually not a bad thing, the main halachik reason for minyan is so that people who need to can say kaddish, so…nice going, and to really take the cake get a hiking buddy to learn with on the trailhead after mincha that sounds like an awesome awesome hike
Keep it up Heshy
By far one of California’s tamer Yetzer Haras, I would say…
“Dude, weren’t you just telling me how you didn’t like the fact that the rabbi didn’t ever speak for that long…”
You want a long talker — you should know to come to San Jose!
Why do you think I come to San Jose? I like the long fire and brimstone filled yeshivish speeches.
After reading this I found that I could relate a lot. but it also got me thinking, and led me to a question that ill share just to open up what i think could be a good topic for conversing….
The question is-
can true khavanah be drawn from your surroundings or is ture khavanah drawn only from HaKodesh Barchu?
Now I know the idea of having windows in Shul… but this i think is different.. ill explain,
Are we to be inspired of HaShem only if we see the awesome sunset, feel the misty fog, see the grandure of the trees? etc.?
And Could it potentially be considered a form idol worship since its drawing inspiration to pray from things that are corporeal, tangable. – Ie fog trees winds sunset, etc.. much like a pagan would an object. Ie statue, fetish, sun moon etc…representing their god?
Not judging either way- I am just asking a question that I find interesting, because Heshy is not the only one I am sure, that feels that way. I have done and thought that way as well.
Should the Idea of Hashem be enough to inspire, true khavanah? how do we reconcile the fact that it is hard to worship a G-d without a visual aid? And should we use said visual aids because- doesnt that defeat the whole point? the point being that Hashem is not a corporeal being and doesnt want us to need those things to worship Him? Isnt that one of the big things that separate us from pagans?
now I know that a breezy day on a mountain inspires, but should it inspire us in prayer? Could that be considered very similar to the way a crucifix inspires an x-ian? Are we allowed as Jews to have crucifixes (metaphorically speaking) in our lives?
our minds naturally need and want these id markers i know i realize, but is this one of those things we must trancend in our natural desire? that desire to see G-d. Should we be content in belief and verve if we dont see G-d, if we dont see the beauty, wonder, triumph, etc?
I’d love to hear everyone’s thoughts…
As long as you have in mind that you are not praying to the beauty of nature, but to it’s creator, I think it’s ok. Hashem created the beauty of this earth to inspire us.
FrumGer, I’m so sorry to be ignorant, but what do you mean when you say “Khavanah” and “HaKodesh Barchu”? Sorry, I don’t know those Jewish terms yet.
First term is Spiritual strength/effort (at least that is how I would explain it)
Second, is another term for G-D.
Literal Is “The holy one, Blessed be He” For HaKodesh Barchu.
I’ve often seen kavannah translated as “intentionality” or “mindfulness.” You try to go into a prayer situation with the proper intention and stay in that mind-space.
(Also useful for humor value. Ex: “You didn’t do the dishes.” “I know, it’s such a shame, I had the right kavannah and everything!”)
but should we need the creation to inspire us? obviously in this situation Heshy needed nature to give him khavanah, and is that potentially assur?
If HaShem gave us the Earth and made it beautiful in order to insipire us to daven with khavanah- couldnt the earth then be considered one big idol to Him? and isnt that against the normative philosophy of Judaism?
In order to bring God’s awesomeness down to our physical level we need things like creation, rabbis and awesome events to inspire us. In the days of Yore (I just needed to use that phrase) the Jews had miracles to inspire them. If you’re on a very high level I’m sure you can take just plain old God, but I doubt anyone is that high.
And im not saying I am that high either, i mean seeing other yidden davening with khavanah pushes mine as well, What i am saying is i wonder if technically its a little bit of idolizing, I mean when you get down to the grass roots, the sub conscience could it be argued that we use corporeal things in this world to inspire us towards Hashem and if we do then isnt that a little just even a little idolatry…,
HaKodesh Barchu- The Holy One Blessed be He
Khavanah- spiritual vigor, sincerity of heart….
I guess I should have read ahead before responding… my bad..
No, thanks to both Anonymous AND Sergeant J for answering my questions. :^)
FrumGer, those are really thought-provoking comments.
In Islam, what you would be trying to ask is, when does worshiping God become shirk? Shirk being a failure, even in some tiny part, to offer up one’s worship to God and God alone.
The Salafist position on shirk is incredibly stringent. Which of course is why drawing Mohammed or even portraying people or animals in art is such a touchy subject.
Isn’t shirk another word for being kufar? Which in Hebrew is kofer? Just showing off my knowledge from asktheimam.com:)
No, shirk is very different. It’s hard to find an equivalent word in English. Idolatry would be the closest cousin, but it goes way beyond that. Shirk would be giving ANY glory, ANY worship or thankfulness to ANYTHING that is not ~actually~ God — even if it’s in the name of glorifying God.
Shirk could be anything from making a poor imitation of His creation that other men will admire (painting a picture of a human figure) to going through the motions of observance while some part of your heart is whispering “isn’t it great that other men see me worshiping here so piously or giving so generously and think me to be good!”
An extreme example would be that one of the first thing the Wahhabists did when they took Saudi Arabia was desecrate, indeed obliterate, the graves of some of the holiest figures in Islam. Out of fear that people were making shrines of these graves, making pilgrimages to see them, and this was a desecration of God’s exclusive holiness. Archaeology is greatly derided by the extreme Salafist Muslim for the same reason.
Or, for another example, if you Google “Islamic clothing” and look at the top 10 retail sites, you’ll notice that some show full models wearing the modest clothing advertised, and some show human models but the faces are blurred out to obliterate individuality, and some will show clothing on artificial mannequins with recognizable human features like lips or eyebrows — and then a few will only display clothing on nearly-shapeless white mannequins …. That’s a pretty good indicator of where each business is coming from on the Islamic theological spectrum, and where they stand on shirk.
Has anyone here ever heard the alternate tradition of Satan rebelling against God because he (Satan) loathed shirk, and was offended to be asked to bow down and give worship to anything other than God Himself, even though it was God who asked in the first place? That’s another interesting story.
Really fascinating stuff Mahla. Thanks for clarifying that for me.
I know there are some Lubavitch types that cut off the noses of their kids’ dolls so it isn’t a question of idol worship (avoda zara). But destroying graves of respected Islamic figures. Wow. That sounds really insane. Makes me realize that the fights we Jews have are downright cordial in comparison!
Mahla, I just “wiki”ed Shirk, and yes exactly my points or questions… You nailed it.
:^)
I guess this is what’s good about being a girl in Judaism. I don’t have to worry about being part of a minyan so this wouldn’t be a question. Too bad I have nowhere to hike:)
C’mon, even if you live in an urban center you must have SOMEWHERE to hike! You might just have to commute a bit to get there … like my poor Mom, who lives in the O.C. …. :^)
Unfortunately I’m just too pregnant to hike! I can’t walk too fast without my abdominal muscles cramping up. Oh well, just a month and a half to go…
Kofer is from my knowledge is a synonym for apikoros, apostate, and heritic… the word shirk means to share worship of G-d with other objects, persons, ideas or other gods… their paths on the definition trail cross but they are have two separate distinctive meanings…
Exactly, the kafir is the non-believer.
Hey Mahla, just curious about why you are interested in Heshy’s blog.
Because it’s a great blog. :^) I’m keenly interested in comparative religion and I’m interested in having a good chuckle, so what’s not to like? This blog is informative, entertaining and thought-provoking. :^)
u should’ve followed ur old friend y”h on this one. U went shul and this post is still boring me to tears.
“Yetzer Tov: Even so, davening with a minyan without kavannah is better than davening alone with kavannah.”
In Shilchan Aruch it says precisely the opposite (if I remember correctly).
Laughter heals, connects us. Thanks so much for touching the hearts of so many in a healing way. The earnest intent here and the struggle to make sure to do the good inclination, or even to try and figure out which is which, is something of a tzaddik way. Intent. Thanks very much.