One of my biggest taivya’s (desires) is reading, I hate movies and TV, but reading has always been my nisayon and now I’ve decided to stop reading all together because I cannot find anything good and kosher to read. I remember laughing in yeshiva when the rabbis told us that books were evil, but I now understand why this is so and why I must change my evil ways.
Unlike movies and TV, goyishe books have always been somewhat accepted by the community. Sure, there are various ways that one can check to see if the book is kosher, like opening to random pages and finding explicit writings, but these are not foolproof and therefore books have never really been glatt kosher. Reading secular books is like holding of the OU, everyone knows it’s not really the best, but the yetzer harah gets us to lower our madreiga by convincing us it’s ok.
While one can get their news from Hamodia and their magazine material from mishpacha and ami, finding a good glatt kosher heimishe book to read is not so easy. I’ve searched far and wide and have come to the conclusion that I will have to read these cliche frum novels about baalei teshuva searching for their long lost frum holocaust survivor family members in South America.
I guess I’ll have to start reading English seforim for entertainment, since anyone who knows a blatt gemara realizes that all English seforim are just for entertainment anyway, one can’t possibly consider reading an English Kitzur Shulchan Aruch to be learning!
If anyone has suggestions as to what I can read to stave off the yetzer harah and his evil goyishe literature it would be appreciated.
Find frum novels on 4torah.com

You can learn more practical Halachah from two hours of studying the English Kitzur Shulchan Aruch than 200 hours of Talmud study.
If you really need kosher secular books, then try books about: secular history, animals, birds, foreign languages, math, chemistry, chess, etc.
The Kitzur Shulchan Aruch is OK, but if you study it use the one with commentaries from the Mishna Berurah, etc., because much of the Kitzur is not reflective of current practice (or practical realities like electricity). Shaarei Halachah by R’ Zev Greenberg is a more practical equivalent (it even calls itself the Kitzur Shulchan Aruch for our times).
No Shakespeare? No Milton? No Byron? No Woolf? No Joyce? No Dickens? No Faulkner? No Kafka? No Proust? No Auden?
No thanks.
The former Rosh Yeshiva of YU Rav Aharon Lichtenstein had a Ph.D. in literature, so it’s clearly possibly be frum and be into goyishe literature. There’s an increasing amount of frum literature out there, though, and not all of it’s bad — see a recent discussion on YWN’s Coffee Room.
Like
Clearly he got the phd before he was chozer biteshuva
Wrong! Rav Lichtenstein is the embodiment of torah u’mada and an intellectual and halachic giant.
Zelig the purpose of talmud isn’t practical halacha. far from it.
Heshy I heard that books are worse than movies/TV since there’s no explicit picture you can make up whatever in your head. Kudos to you.
Listen the gordian knot is a quality piece of literature. The intricate plot details and nuanced characters combine to create a gripping narrative. Not to mention In The Spiders Web, The Inquisition and Eye Of The Storm…all fine literature indeed.
P.S. Anyone else heard growing up the urban legend that Chaim Eliav and Yair Weinstock are the same person?
Read the classics; Marcus Lehman, Zelig Shachanowitz or the all time master Chaim Walder.
I give you a heter to read Game of Thrones because it’s awesome.
Just like an erev…IMHO last book was a disappointment though..
Tanya. Then you’re REALLY gonna learn about the yetzer harah (& you can even halachically learn it with your chabadnik wife!)
Funny, I was just reading bits from Willard V.O. Quine and Cardinal Newman on the train today. Sorta in memory of my uncle the philosophy professor, who would have been 84 today if he hadn’t died 8 years ago Rosh Chodesh Elul.
http://old.thedailystar.com/news/community/obits/2004/08/ob0826.html
By all accounts Rabbi Neusner and Pope Benedict are longtime personal friends. I bet they mostly talk football. But when they talk shop there probably aren’t a dozen people in the world who can keep up.
This is satire right? I’m sure I’ll see you at City Lights tonight.
More of a dog eared and green apple books guy
Next time you come up here you need to make hajj Portland style – go to Powell’s.
I used to hide my secular literature in a bookshelf in an upstairs bedroom. Oh, that’s a comment for the earlier post about how to look frummer than you actually are: hide your secular literature in a bookshelf in an upstairs bedroom…
One of the problems of this website is that lately it’s hard to tell when a post is supposed to be satirical, funny or serious. If this post were either of the first two, I’d expect something with at least a subatomic level of merit like “50 Shades of Black Hats.”
So I’ll have to take you seriously and assume it’s off to the kolel for you. What occupation does not require reading? I am sure that somewhere there is even a tome entitled “Fundamentals of Ditch Digging.” Of course, “sit and learn” and you don’t have to read anything “goyishe” except for maybe some applications for Section 8, Medicaid and Food Stamps.
I thought made it pretty obvious when I bashed English seforim and said they weren’t counted as learning.
Sadly, satire that’s too close to the truth is lost on people. Lots of people say that with a straight face.
This is why editors exist. It was far from obvious.
the great american novel- philip roth
the art of choosing: sheena iyengar
I read David Copperfield and Great Expectations in high school. That got rid of my yetzer harah to read secular books, not permanently, but for a while. Then I read Kane and Abel by Jeffrey Archer and that also got rid of my desire to read secular books for a while. After that I read Rule of Four and that also got rid of the desire for a while.
So if you want to get rid of the desire to read secular books, just read any of the ones I mentioned, and when you get the desire again, read one of the others.
You’ve still got The Avram Davidson Treasury and Herevilleand haven’t read them? Davidson was a frum Jew. Barry Deutsch is Jewish but not frum. His Orthodox readers loved Hereville. It’s the most affectionate portrayal of heimishe life you’ll ever see in a graphic novel.
After you finish those try Jewish Pirates of the Caribbean, a well-researched history of Jews and their relation to the Barbary pirates, Caribbean pirates, migration to the New World and the re-establishment of Jewish communities in Britain and the Netherlands. Since you’ll be in the area anyway pick up Mark Kurlansky’s Salt: A World History. What could be more kosher than salt and cod? Besides, there’s plenty of Jewish content.
For professional development try Claudia Roden’s The Book of Jewish Food. It’s two things in one. It’s simply the best Kosher cookbook out there, won all kinds of awards, covers everything from Black and White Jewish cooking in India to chopped liver. It’s also a rich history of Jews from around the world, their food and their relations to it. DANGER: One look and you’ll realize how much better Sephardic and Mizrahi cooking is than Ashkenazi.
Going a little further afield Chris Moriarty’s The Inquisitor’s Apprentice is very good. It’s about a fantasy about a Jewish kid from Hester Street set in the early 20th century. Russian immigrant parents. Anti-Semitic Edison. Houdini (also a Jew BTW). Kabbalists. J. P. Morgan. Teddy Roosevelt. How can you go wrong?
Still in SF&F there’s Jack Dann’s classic collection Wandering Stars. It’s a great collection of science fiction by Jews on Jewish themes. If “Unto the Fourth Generation” doesn’t bring tears to your eyes you don’t have a soul. A bunch of greats from Bernard Malamud and Isaac Baneshevis Singer to Robert Silverberg and Avram Davidson. The sequel, More Wandering Stars is alright but not nearly as good.
Then there’s a series that has me scratching my head, Merkabah Rider. It starts off with Tales of a High Planes Drifter and continues with The Mensch With no Name and Have Glyphs, Will Travel. The fourth and final book will come out later this year. It’s weird, supernatural Westerns about a (very Orthodox) rabbi who is chasing his aporikos teacher. Not sure if it’s frum enough, but where else are you going to get Molech, the Lilim and all the rest in the Old West written by someone who has spent a lot of time learning the material?
OK, just finished The Mensch With no Name. I knew things with too many tentacles would be making an appearance. Ia Klippoth! Cthulhu (yms) fhtagn!
Just posted a bunch of books that probably qualify. Somehow they ended up in the Bad Words Filterbasket. Should show up in a few hours.
I was thinking Fifty Shades of Grey would be a perfectly kosher read. Even better, read it with your wife. Not sure why you would even need chosson or kallah classes after reading that.
If you want good erotica that accurately reflects the BDSM community 50 Shades is lousy. The author admitted it was an attempt to capitalize on certain other bestsellers by adding stuff she didn’t have a real-life understanding of.
She succeeded to the tune of over a million dollars a week in sales. Le sigh.
Honorless Horseradish:
1) Any books read as school assignments automatically become 10x worse/more boring than if read for fun.
2) Never read Archer.
3) Hey, Rule of Four was great! Of course, it helps that a) I already knew something about the Hypnerotomachia, and b) I went to Princeton. Although I’ve never been in the Ivy basement, and the steam tunnels don’t interconnect all over campus the way they do at Columbia.
Read the Song of Solomon, not in an Artscroll translation. It makes Danielle Steele look mild by contrast.
When one argues the perils secular of literature one of the first problems raised is “the explicit and implicit sexual references”. What exactly is the problem? Most probably the advocate will note that reading these sort of fantasies and scenes will cause the casual reader to start having forming images in his mind which are deemed forbidden. This is a valid argument that one cannot avoid. It would be audacious to think that one can read “Fifty Shades of Gray” and not picture in his mind these debased scenes. However, it is important to note that the mere mention of certain anatomical areas of a male or female does not categorically bar the permissibility to read. Is there not an entire tractate in the Bavli which discusses the rules of a Menstruant? Is not the Song of Songs replete with references to passion, love, and romance? It is clear that the issue is not the mere mention which is problematic, but rather the author’s goal to elicit sexual arousing feelings which exclude the reading of a book. Therefore, a distinction should be made between reading a James Patterson mass fiction novel (which is probably a problem) and a Herman Wouk masterpiece.
http://grestudentblog.blogspot.com/2012/07/lure-of-literature.html
Well said. I think Daf Yomi just finished (finally) with the explicit parts of Niddah. Illustrating each page of that is not easy. (http://mkerzner.blogspot.com/2012/06/niddah-16-multiple-acts.html)
Playboy. For the articles, of course !
Actually try reading Breshis and then tell me whether this version of “Dallas on the Euphrates” is satire or not. Hashem got so fed up with Avraham who didn’t get the goof of the Akeda that he stopped talking to him. Then of course we got Yosef the role model for both Dudi Kravetz not to mention every Boy Toy to come, as well as his brother Yehuda who invented the lead male role in “Pretty Woman”.
Lure of literature. There are three problem with secular literature which need to be discussed honestly. I saw the writer at grestudentblog.blogspot do an interesting job. A. sexual references B. Violence and crime C. Bad values and ideas. Each must be dealt with.
And if you manage to stamp out all three you have a fourth to deal with, tooth grinding boredom.
If you not a classics person there are some very interesting Jewish books around that are off the beaten track one is “Eyes to see” by yom tov schwartz talking about life&learning before the holocaust&the change to now there are others by the same publishing house called Urim which defy the usual follow blindly literature they discuss all the classic questions hair covering,segregation etc and they are usually very well written&researched! Alternatively get them to put u to sleep until this madness has passed!
Seriously, if readers of this blog want a Jewish read that rivals the best of haredi scholarshipbut is probably banned in Lakewood try studying the “Talmudic Essays”, of Emmanuelle Levinas. Levinas was an observant Jew, considered by the secular world one of the greatest 20th century moral philosophers. Once a year he would give a Sheur before a European Jewish conference on a talmudic text. His approach to learning and text is unique and mind bending and for you Yeshivish snobs an intellectual challenge of the first order.
…and there is that section near the back where the intellectuals who read Levinas sit and talk all during davenning. Near them sits the clean shaven retired Rabbi, the only man who actually understands what Levinas said. He never corrects them, but occasionally cracks a smile when overhearing their arguments. And there by the clock sits the guys who read anything from Benny Lau and Nati Helfgot. These are the guys who play baseball on Sunday, but only after they learn a few pages of She’iltot or Rav Acahi Gaon. I see that no one sits near the quiet sefardi guy as he reads Haim Sabato. Me? I’m not reading my Leibovits anymore. Instead, I’m peering through the mechizta and staring at the one woman who is longingly looking at the Rabbi as he gets to the climax of his sermon. She catches my eyes and smiles…
Tales from the Intellectual Shul
Thanks. I’ll look him up … the Cambridge Edition is $75 but only $10 on the Kindle.
I guess reading stieg larsson’s dragon tattoo series is out of the question, great series
Read “The King of Schnorrers” by Israel Zangwill if you want frum satire 100 years before frumsatire.com. (or even better download it from librivox.com to hear it read in marvelous accents by Adrian Praetzellis)
http://librivox.org/the-king-of-schnorrers-by-israel-zangwill/
Read “Good as Gold” and “G’d Knows” by Joseph Heller if you want seriously un-frum satire.
And tell DRosenbach to read “Conversion of the Jews” by Philip Roth so he can meditate on the Ishmaelian “Mary hadda get laid.” vs. the Akivan “G-d can do anything He wants to.”
Is this dude fucking serious or just playing? I can’t believe this dude. Wow. What a turnaround. Guess he finally got brainwashed by the same people he always made fun of. Enjoy the brainwashed life loser. Won’t be too long before you force your wife to wear a burka.
I am fairly sure this site is still called frum SATIRE .net and that the entire frummie population of the USA does not have the kavannah to brainwash our iconoclastic Heshy.
why???? even as a joke, I don’t find giving up secular literature funny. reading brought me closer to judaism…..no joke. if you are afraid your religion will waver if you are exposed to literature means that you must look deeper into ur faith and principals.