Random

Frum couple goes a bit extreme on “The Lean”

At frum engagement parties, commonly know as Vorts and L’chaim’s the couple makes sure not to touch in their pictures. Most frum couples typically lean in toward each other, almost touching but not quite, this pose as officially known as The Lean. At my engagement party this Saturday night I hope to take some good leaning pictures (In June we will be able to hold hands like normal couples at last) The picture below is the Extreme Lean, because God forbid the couple feel each others sexual tension or body heat. Notice the girl’s hair style – AKA the Bump.

Picture has been removed at the request of the photographer who had no idea how it got public – welcome to frummies not knowing how to use Facebook.
Hat Tip Dani Klein

Letters to the Editor 39 letters since 2020

  1. They look so nervous and aidel. And that’s after spending ten minutes shmoozing in a room with their parents hovering around. I cant find anything wrong with this.

          1. She does look young but some girls just look young. I looked 16 from age 13 until recently when I now look 20 to 25, though I’m 36.

  2. The fact is, these people procreate quite effectively — and yet they keep a distance of 3 or 4 feet apart. And now you know that what long jacket is covering. Impressive bro’.

  3. It’s really not tznius that you put up a picture of a girl on your blog, you know.

    also, it’s really disturbing that it looks like their age gap could be that of a father and daughter.

    1. My guess is that they’re only a couple of years apart. He looks older because of the beard, but he’s just an older teenager – his face is very young and his beard isn’t full.

      1. uhh, did u check that he is losing a little hair?! has to be at least early twenties and that girl better be his sister

  4. I really think you should take down the photo, I saw the post on your facebook wall that someone sent you yesterday and read all the comments under this photographer’s photo. How he put (if my memory serves me right) “How old does this girl look? She’s 16 I should know because I photographed her parent’s engagement 17 years ago”
    Then how everyone started agreeing she is too young but then the comments turned to disgusted people who shamed him and said how they would never use his service. Due to fact the couple obviously doesn’t know he put it online and wrote a comment that made fun of them.
    I went back today to see the new comments and he’s deleted it. I’m sure its hurt his business and he was a fool for doing that.
    As a modern orthodox photographer (in the making) I’m very aware at the frum attitude to posting photographs on the photographers website. I’ve had a few frum clients and most they strictly don’t like their photos online especially ones of kids (some kind of pedo paranoia). Also there is the obvious thing that a lot of very frum people tend not to like the internet, so when the photographer posted this picture he knew they wouldn’t have facebook so they wouldn’t see it.
    There is also an issue of tznuit which I’m still unsure of. I photographed a girl who used to non religious at her wedding it was an amazing photo but she wouldn’t let me submit it to an article as she felt it was untznuit.
    I think the frum attitude to the internet is a tad over the top, luckly I’ve found chabad clients who let me use their photos to advertise 🙂

    Another small point, there is also an issue of copyright when it comes to photography the photographer has full copyright over this picture and you really need his permission to use it. (this doesn’t bother me so much but it will him)

    This couple didn’t agree to this picture being online most likely and definitely not on your blog. I think its not fair for you to use it. They don’t deserve mockery (mostly from the photographer who was in the wrong)

    1. I agree with miriam. These people aren’t public figures; they aren’t legitimate targets for public mockery aimed at them personally. And all this plus copyright violation in a single post!

  5. note this comment from The Lean 2009:

    July 26, 2009 at 2:49 PM
    I like the ones where the guy and girl are each on the side of the giant floral arrangement he sent her. It’s like they must be in their own zipcode or something.

  6. its one thing to disagree with their principles, but its another to mock them. Typical of the left wing types who preach on having an open mind towards blacks gays and and scum of the earth, but then mock people who have a more religious standard

    1. At least we don’t put them in the same category as “scum of the earth,” like you’re doing with blacks and gays.

  7. This is so lawsuit waiting to happen.

    Here’s how it goes down.

    1. Frumsatire reader who is an underemployed law school graduate sees facebook post from photographer and this post.
    2. He finds out who couple is and sues photographer for a whole bunch of torts and contract violations, half of which are probably decent claims.
    3. Since it is state court, he survives summary judgment, and photographer is forced to settle to avoid going to trial and losing all his business when he is potentially bankrupted by large verdict, and nobody wants to hire him anymore because he is a creep.
    4. Photographer sues Heshy for copyright violation, because he is mad that it got more public even than he had recklessly intended.

    Not to worry, Dan is not an underemployed law school graduate. But one of this months 70,000 unique viewers probably is.

      1. I am not a lawyer and this is not legal advice. (that’s me being OCD.)

        Copyright in American Law is automatic, and you don’t need to file for it nor put a little c in a circle. You own a copyright on all mediums of expression you produce, including photographs. So the photographer owns a copyright in this picture, unless he transferred it to the guy who hired him by contract.

        One of the ways you violate copyright is by “reproducing” it. Posting it on a website is certainly reproduction. Interestingly, we are possibly also “reproducing” it since at least one federal case has held that when your computer copies it on its RAM it is reproduction.

        The penalty for copyright infringement is up to 150,000 per violation in civil penalty. 17 U.S.C.A. § 504. Additionally, the plaintiff can be granted attorneys fees if they win. 17 U.S.C.A. § 505.

        Additionally, if the infringement was “willful” and “for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain,” then there is criminal liability. 17 U.S.C.A. § 506. I don’t know what those terms mean, you’d need to read the caselaw. The criminal penalty is up to a year in prison it looks like. 18 U.S.C.A. § 2319. (But since Heshy is frum, we’ll say it is anti-semitism. Hee hee).

      2. Any professional photographer maintains copyright on his/her images. Using someone else’s copyrighted image without permission is a violation of copyright, whether or not the copyright owner chooses to pursue it legally. Granted, if the photographer posted this image to Facebook then he opened this can of worms himself, or at least he handed Heshy the can opener, but it’s still wrong.

    1. Dan,

      Don’t quit your day job. Even an unemlployed law graduate knows that solicitation is grounds for disbarment.

      Moreover, using this picture, as well as all the discussion surrounding it, is probably well within the grounds of both “fair use” and “fair comment.”

    1. I was imagining that after some plaintiffs lawyer sues him and puts him out of business (he really should be put out of business), he will get mad and sue Heshy because he is anti Semitic.

    2. >The copyright issue is moot

      It isn’t, though. That’s the thing. I agree that the photographer is unlikely to pursue it, and it’s not going to turn into a legal case. But the photo is still here, and its being here is an infringement on the artists’s copyright. I know since the advent of the Internet and YouTube people mostly don’t care about this, but that doesn’t change that it’s an infringement and wrong.

  8. Riddle, how do married men say “none of your business” when they’re asked about the whereabouts of their better half?

    “Oh, she’s at the mikva” – no other line is a verbal middle finger to a married friend like this!

Write a letter to the editor

Random