The Holy Temple in Jerusalem, which stood as two distinct structures spanning nearly ten centuries, is no longer extant, but the site of the sanctuary is considered by Jewish tradition to be the holiest site in the universe. Not only that, but the entire Temple Mount upon which the the sanctuary stood is revered, despite it lying in ruins and having been usurped by others through the centuries.
This is in fascinating contrast to Mount Sinai, the location of which is a mystery. One might think that Mount Sinai is at least equivalent in terms of its sacredness, yet we know not where it is.
Meir Simcha of Dvinsk, known by the name of his biblical commentary, the Meshech Chochma, explains that the Temple Mount is worthy of veneration because it was sanctified by people, whereas Mount Sinai was sanctified by God (Exodus 12:21). So when God was done with Sinai, it reverted back to its plain and undecorated status, but the Temple Mount, consecrated by man, retains its status until desacralized by man — and because Judaism maintains that we are to anticipate the rebuilding of the Temple with the coming of the Messiah, the site maintains its holy status.

It’s a cute vort, but I think that if we knew the location of Har Sinia, we’d consider it pretty holy too. The whole people sanctifying vs. God sanctifying is an ad hoc attempt to religiously explain a simple reality: we know where the Beis HaMikdash was because it stood in its various incarnations for a thousand years and a lot of it is still there; Sinia on the other hand is a mountain in the middle of nowhere with a myth attached to it. Like many vorts, it needlessly complicates something that can be explained in simple practical terms.
> The Holy Temple in Jerusalem, which stood as two distinct structures
More, if you count renovations. I find it ironic that it’s Herod’s version of the Beis Hamikdash that we remember most vividly.
> the site of the sanctuary is considered by Jewish tradition to be the holiest site in the universe.
Only since Chezkiyah decided it was politically expedient to make the Beis HaMikdash the only legal place to bring karbanos and had the other temples destroyed. Can you imagine what that must have been like for people? Government officials destroy the shrine where for generations your family has worshipped Hashem and tell you that from now on, you can only worship Hashem in Yerushalayim. The only reason he’s remembered as Chezkiyah ha tzaddik and not as a monster is because the winners write the history books.
Blah Blah Blah….
I Liked it Hesh!
“Only since Chezkiyah decided it was politically expedient to make the Beis HaMikdash the only legal place to bring karbanos and had the other temples destroyed.”
What are you talking about? The prohibition against offering sacrifices in any place other than the Bais HaMikdash is an explicit law in the Torah text itself, it’s not something instituted by a king or anyone else. When it says “in the place I will chose for you”, that is Hashem telling us that ONLY in that place are sacrifices permitted, according to ALL commentaries. Go back to Slifkin’s munchkins and leave the real Torah talk to them that know.
Nate~
You are full of hate. I’d ask you to leave and never come back, but it’s not my blog.
I thought it was cute, too.
In response to the seemingly contrived nature of the Meshech Chochma’s approach, I would say in his defense that Exodus 19:13 does place a time limit on the sanctity of Mount Sinai — at the sounding of the shofar, the people and the cattle may breach the gates and ascend the mountain. The surprise of this immediately following the revelation may serve to indicate the sudden loss of holiness, which seems key.
Ah, so that’s what M.B. meant. I was thinking more along the lines of places like Kever Rochel. I’m sure that if we knew where Har Sinia was, it would be regular stop on the tourist holy site tour. “when God was done with Sinai, it reverted back to its plain and undecorated status” seems to mean that after matan torah was over, Har Sinai was no longer of any interest.
Well, yes, that is what the Meshech Chochma is asserting. You may find it contrived, because we don’t know where it is, but if you look at this from the other direction — why don’t we know where it is? — you may be more comfortable with the Meshech Chochma’s approach. (Granted, Revelation at Sinai happened much earlier than most anything in Jewish history.)
To G#
Actually it is explicit in the Torah Exodus 19:13 that once the revelation was over the mountain lost its sanctity, nothing to do with uncertainty of location.
Um, no it doesn’t. The pesukim there are about Hashem telling Moshe to tell the Bnei Yisroel how to get ready for matan torah. There’s nothing about any time limits on Har Sinai’s kedusha.
Just take that in for a moment, it is humanity that has the power to make something holy! It is the Jewish people that made the temple holy, they believed it and it is.
Could you stop with dvar torahs?! it just doesn’t fit with the mind set i have when coming to this site LOL
Joey, do you think I hack into this blog and post stuff uninvited? I post Divrei Torah at the behest of Heshy Fried.
I like it. Short and sweet.
Thank you.
There was once a penny stock PIL that jumped from 3 cents to 21 cents and someone had given me advanced knowledge, but I didn’t go for it because I didn’t trust the guy; if it’s any indication, he had a pet monkey — literally. Moreover, I thought it might be illegal, and I didn’t want to go to prison with this guy and his monkey.
Every time you comment, I think about that fateful moment in my life.
I dont think we can desanctify anything. DOn’t we say maalin bekodesh veain moridin. This rule wouldn’t apply to God who can do anything, but it would apply to us.
Assuming kedusha is designated a priori for temporary purposes, MBV”M ought not apply.
What i’m saying is that the M”Ch’s idea that a Jewish consensus can revoke an object’s kedusha status is new to me, and seems to contradict this well-known law.
Perhaps Mount Sinai and Har Habayis ca n both be viewed as tashmishei mitzvah, and when we’re done with them, they can be thrown out. We’re just not done with Har Habayis yet.
G*3 – where do you get your info? The Torah explicitly states that Hashem says “the place where I shall chose”, referring to where the korbonos are to be brought. This was the Bais HaMikdash. Chose implies to the exclusion of every other place. All other altars were prohibited once the Temple was built, and this occurred way way before Chizkiahu.
That depends on one’s understanding of where the Torah comes from, and what exactly it was that was “discovered” in the Beis Hamikdash.
Huh? You talk in the same riddles here that you do on Slifkin’s heretical blog. There is no “understanding of where the Torah comes from.” It comes from God. Nobody of any character disagrees with that.
What do you mean “discovered”? Can you just speak English for a change? God I swear all you Slifkinites are the same. Psychobabblers and philosobabblers. And logic scramblers. If you say A then B and C and blah blah blah. There are only 2 letters in logic that mean anything. F and U.
Nelson~
I am surprised at your lack of civility — please understand that G*3 is merely approaching this from his perspective and not yours. You may disagree, and you may do so vehemently, but please do not do so belligerently.
G*3~
We’ve discussed this at length both on and off this blog, but certainly you agree that we cannot begin to talk Torah unless we take for granted certain things. There’s no use in discussing the difference between klir rishon and iruy kli rishon, or between Tisha B’Av and shaar taaneisim unless we agree that such debates are predicated on the existence of a god, that god being the God of Moses and that he actually, and very directly, gave us directions in the form of the Torah that we have now (both written and oral). We cannot very well ask why certain spots on an esrog invalidate it while certain spots do not, if you will come along and say, “Well, that’s assuming there’s even a divinely inspired text detailing that we use an esrog altogether.”
So your point is well taken, and it’s a good point, and for halachic Jews to cast you off as a heretic because you ask these questions is improper, unless you are here to mock and be cynical. And perhaps I have been guilty of some mockery here and there, and I’ve thought about that and have come to regret my tone in many places — but, well, at least for this discussion and others similar, let’s take the fundamentals of the religion to be a given, because without that, we cannot discuss anything.
G3
R we reading the same verse. It says, “when their is a long shofar blast, you may go up the mountain” i.e. people, cattle etc. may now go up the mountain.
I understood that to mean that once Hashem was done with it, people no longer had to stay away from Har Sinai. I’m not sure that means it no longer has any kedusha. We are freely allowed on the har habayis (except the actual footprint of the Beis Hamikdash), and that doesn’t detract from the kedusha of the har habayis. If we knew where Har Sinai was, surely we would ascribe to it at least the same kedusha as places like Kever Rochel and the Mearas Hamachpeila.
Alright — well, the Meshech Chochma and others take it to mean that Mount Sinai lost everything.
Do those places have any kedusha? They are the burial sites of the righteous, but is there a real sanctity to these sites?