The ratio of the circumference of a circle to its radius can be approximated in the form of a fraction as 22/7, although it is more commonly expressed in decimal form.
According to the talmud, 22/8 is the fraction that represents the character of God.
R’ Levi taught: the properties of God are unlike those of man — for God’s blessings span 22 letters and His curses span 8, while man’s blessings span 8 letters and his curses span 22. (Bavli Bava Basra 88b)
What this means, as explained by Rashi (ad loc), is that the blessings in Leviticus (26:3-13) begin with the letter aleph and end with the letter tav — spanning all 22 letters of the Hebrew alphabet — while the curses in Leviticus (26:14-43) begin with a vav and end with a mem — spanning but 8 letters of the alphabet. In Deuteronomy, though, the pattern is reversed: the blessings (28:1-14) begin with the letter vav and end with the letter mem (8 letters, identical to the previous calculation) and the curses (28:15-68) begin with a vav and end with a hey — thus spanning all 22 letters of the Hebrew alphabet.
A clever calculation, but it certainly begs the following question: why are the sections in Deuteronomy referred to as belonging to man?
The mishna (Bavli Megillah 3:6) states that, historically, we did not interrupt the reading of the curses to change readers, which in modern times would take the form of a ban on splitting the curses between two people called to the Torah. Abaye (31b) qualifies the statement in the mishna, limiting the ban to the curses in Leviticus with the following explanation: “u’Moshe mipi hagevurah amran” — “and Moses stated this from on high,” in contrast to the curses in Deuteronomy, which are described by “u’Moshe mipi atzmo amran” — “and Moses stated this by himself.”
Rashi (Deuteronomy 28:23) provides textual proof to this end, revealing the obvious differences between the self-referential tone of the Leviticus curses [“v’im lo sishma’u li” — “if you do not listen to me” (Leviticus 26:14)] and the curses in Deuteronomy, which appear in second person [“im lo sishma b’kol Hashem Elokecha” — “if you do not listen to God Almighty” (28:15)]. Although there are those who maintain a contrary opinion (such as R’ Yochanan and Reish Lakish), there is no recorded objection in the talmud to Abaye’s position.
Now despite the suggestion that such a position may promote heresy, the biblical and talmudic commentators do not conjure such fear for many other instances of near-heretical interpretation of biblical verses, such as those referring to Moses seeing God wearing clothes (end of Exodus 33). In fact, it appears that opposition to such an assertion — that Deuteronomy was a Mosaic innovation — was primarily from the sages of Israel, where sectarian influence was strong. Abaye, from Babylonia, was not faced with such ideological defiance and so did not hesitate to speak his mind.
But what’s the point? Why does it matter where the text of Deuteronomy came from? Because there are those who claim that a multitude of authors each wrote different sections of, well, what we refer to as the Five Books of Moses, and to account for the striking dissimilarities between the first four books and Deuteronomy, we should be compelled to accept that the text, although later commanded by God to be inscribed as the fifth book to complete the series, was initially Moses’. Is there any practicality that derives from such an assertion? Other than Maimonidian permission to break apart the Deuteronomical curses when calling people to the Torah (Hilchos Tefillah 13:7), there is no real significance. What it does do, however, is explain the textual inconsistencies of Deuteronomy as a function of the Ishmaelian perspective — if Deuteronomy consists of Moses’ words, it was not given together with the rest of the Torah on Sinai. The Torah could not have been given in totality at Sinai, repeated in the Ohel Mo’ed (Tent of Meeting) and repeated once again in Arvos Mo’av (the Steppes of Moab), as suggested by R’ Akiva, if it hadn’t yet been completed, as suggested by R’ Ishmael. So when we see opposition to Abaye in the form of aggressive refutation by the likes of R’ Yochanan (“whomever says that Moses admonished the Israelites on his own is but a sinner), it is not to be taken as the position of Judaism any more than it should be taken as a position in Judaism — and one that necessarily defends the honor of no less than R’ Akiva himself.
Search 4 Torah at 4torah.com

what the hell are you spewing?
I do not understand your question. Do you not know how to read or do you just have poor reading comprehension? If I could effectively summarize what I wrote, I would have done so in lieu of the post above.
Overall, I thought it was quite a cogent piece…perhaps you could be more specific.
Yeah there’s probably a more constructive way of giving criticism than what the hell are you spewing.
It’s a complex article, so I’m a little overwhelmed on the commenting part… I will say, I think numbers and math have always been an interesting part of Judaism, and if nothing else for me (because I am not a JDS girl), it lends a complexity and depth to the text that I can see people spending lifetimes trying to understand.
As for the rest, this piece is terribly dense. I do like the idea that several different ideas can existing within Judaism, without a single concept being deemed “right,” and the others being considered “heresy.” Beautifully written article!
I see textual and mathematical tricks not as evidence for belief but as evidence of belief. In other words, I’m not suggesting that the 22/8 provides testimony to anything other than our already established convictions — much like the argument from design.
And thank you.
Anonymous:
I ask myself the exact same question every time he writes something, be it a comment or a post. I suspect he is lonely and this is his way of telling the world he exists. Ad nauseum doesn’t even begin to describe his diatribes.
An exercise in mental masturbation.
To anonymous and Shlomo: you’re the reason we’re still in galus.
Shabbat Shalom
Really? I thought it was because of the Hot Chanies.
Not unless they spend their time bashing people online.
Must be because of tznius then.
> According to the talmud, 22/8 is the fraction that represents the character of God.
The rest of the post is interesting, in an academic kind of way, but what in the world does this bit mean? It’s a grammatically correct sentence, but it has no meaning.
Is it meaningful to say that a piece of music sounds orange? Or that a fruit tastes like 7?
It was an attempt at intellectual humor — I thought it was funny to refer to the ratio of God’s blessings to his curses as a fraction that would pique everyone’s interest.
This is a satire blog, is it not? Or do I have to write “sex, sex, sex” for it to be funny?
I guess I don’t appreciate your sense of humor.
It’s an interesting bit of historical/textual criticism but as a writer I think 1) as written, it’s over the heads of most of your audience 🙂 2) you need to expand the last section so that the readers understand more clearly what the various arguments related to the Mosaic authorship of Deuteronomy are and how (and I think this was your main point but it got a bit lost in the text) legitimate mainstream Jewish thinkers throughout history have taken opposing views without casting anathemas on those who disagreed with them.
1) Although I was thoroughly surprised to find that Rationalist Frummie was in high school, I don’t think this is necessarily over the heads of most of my audience. Granted, there are those who, by their own obstinacy, will not take anything I write as potentially insightful (such as Shlomo), all one needs to do is open their mind to see that what they’ve heard their entire lives is only what has filtered through the sieve of their teachers’ and principals’ liking.
2) My point was not to endorse the documentary hypothesis, but to merely point out that Deuteronomy (in particular) exhibits quite the range of unique and inconsistent factors that are quite readily explained should it be accepted that these were the words of Moses. I did see it as a direct continuum of the Akivan/Ishmaelian split that I’ve come to appreciate of late and thought it apropos to the ongoing exhibition of this debate. And I do sense that most every one of my posts eventually tumbles into the “there are multiple ways to interpret things but this is the way I’m advocating” discussion, so I didn’t think that notion was in any need of special attention.
But those were two well-directed comments — thank you!
I’m going to guess that most of your readers are not completely fluent in a discussion of the Akivan/Ishmaelian split. 🙂 I’m going to include myself in that group. Perhaps a bit of pre-work for the readers might have helped.
Well, I hope with my weekly expositions, we can all seek to widen our understanding of that which has been severely undertaught in yeshiva (and, without a doubt, in Catholic school). 🙂
Or rather, I think you’re saying they (the scholars) differed as to their opinion on the timing of the authorship — that is, to explain the apparent differences between the first four books and Deuteronomy they postulated a different time and circumstances of the writing rather than (as others many do) a different authorship. But maybe you can clarify.
No one disputes that Deuteronomy is unique: “vayidaber Hashem el Moshe lemor” — “God spoke to Moses, saying” shows up not even once, and there is a consistent reference to God in the third person. The book is written in Moses’ voice, and the Sifre (attributed to the school of R’ Ishmael) states no less than 5 times that Moses said to the people, “Not on my own do I tell you this, but rather from the mouth of the Most Holy do I tell you this.” What is the basis for this uniqueness, however, is the question — but certainly not one that may ever come up in the yeshiva in anything but a passing comment that the kids will likely miss anyway.
The Akivan view is that not only was the entire Torah given at Sinai in the year 1312 BCE, but that it preexisted the world, and perhaps even in written form. Many — tannaim, amoraim, geonim, rishonim, acharonim, Christians and Muslims — tackle this and many other related obvious problems, the most basic of which is: if there was no ink and no parchment, no stone and perhaps even no matter prior to the point of time referred colloquially as “Bereishis” as a literal interpretation of Genesis entails, what in the world would such a thing even mean. As with any explanation, if there is an inconsistency to be dealt with, something must bend. The Akivan approach sees nothing wrong with bending rationalism — so suggestions of black fire written on white fire and similar unknowns of colossally mystical proportions are suggested as solutions. The Ishmaelian school prefers, rather, to bend on the very interpretation of various verses that necessitate such bizarre solutions — when viewed from this perspective, though, this doesn’t really amount to bending anything at all, for without the treacherous interpretation of biblical content, there is no subsequent need to clean up after it. It claims, in concert with a very rational reading of the Torah, that the Torah was given little by little over many years.
The general rule “ein mukdam u’me’uchar baTorah” — “there is no earlier or later in the Torah,” which translates loosely as “there is no manner of logical deduction based on chronology of passage location in the Torah,” is one that belonged to the school of R’ Ishmael. Because the Torah was received from God in no particular order, claims the rationale behind this idiom, nothing can be learned from the overall order, although exceptions are made in terms of verses in immediate proximity. The exception to this rule, however, is in the Book of Deuteronomy. Because, claims the Ishmaelians, Deuteronomy was composed by Moses, arranged and prepared as a structured, flowing monologue, things that appear prior to other things can be taken to have been said prior to the things mentioned later, and earlier events can be deduced to have occurred earlier than events mentioned later.
I like the picture.
I had you in mind…